Publication date: November 18, 2026
The Simple Agreement for Future Tokens (SAFT) began as a US instrument. It is now a default template for token pre-sales worldwide. Many SAFTs that reach European lawyers are short, generic and signed in a hurry by parties in different offshore jurisdictions.
In this case study, we analyse an interesting example of such an agreement, one that should be of particular interest to investors. Part of the tokens is bought for cash, and a much larger part is paid for social media promotion. Founders, marketing agencies and influencers will also recognise these deal mechanics. Each of them raises an EU or Polish law issue that is easy to miss.
The issuer is a company incorporated outside the EU. It is building a blockchain project whose token has not yet been minted. The counterparty is an offshore vehicle controlled by a person with a large crypto-focused social media following.
The consideration has two parts:
Other key terms:
The drafting has defects typical of recycled templates. A key term is used but never defined. Another is defined but never used. The sanctions clause refers to a list that does not exist. One clause says token distribution is fully automated and beyond the issuer’s control. Another gives the issuer full discretion over the release schedule.
| Contract feature | Legal issue | Section below |
| Token declared “not a security” | Classification under MiFID II and MiCA | Qualifying the token |
| Listing as a condition of the deal | Loss of MiCA white paper exemptions | Qualifying the token |
| Tokens paid for promotion | MiCA marketing rules, market manipulation, influencer law | Promotion paid in tokens |
| No governing law or forum | Rome I, jurisdiction, enforcement | No governing law |
| Sole discretion, sole remedy, late-delivery tokens, “as is” | Polish Civil Code limits | Clauses under the Polish Civil Code |
| Tokens as fees for services | PIT, CIT, VAT | Tax |
A SAFT is a contract under which an investor pays now for tokens to be delivered after the network launches. It was developed in the US in 2017 and modelled on the SAFE used in start-up financing.
The US logic was specific. The SAFT itself was treated as a security and sold only to accredited investors under a private placement exemption. The tokens delivered later were meant to be functional “utility” tokens outside securities law.
That logic does not travel to the EU automatically. EU law does not apply the US Howey test, and MiCA has its own definitions of an offer to the public and of a crypto-asset. Under Polish law, a SAFT is an unnamed contract based on freedom of contract (Article 353¹ of the Civil Code). It obliges the issuer to create and transfer a future crypto-asset. It is not an equity or debt instrument unless its terms give rights of that kind.
The safer working assumption for EU purposes is that a pre-sale of tokens under a SAFT forms part of the offer of those tokens. Selling “a right to future tokens” rather than the tokens themselves does not move the deal outside MiCA.
A clause saying the token “is not a security” has no legal effect on its classification. In the EU, classification follows the token’s substance, in three steps.
The token in our case gives no profit, governance or redemption rights. On its face it falls into the third category. The answer could change if the project’s marketing promised returns, buy-backs or revenue sharing. Contract and marketing must therefore tell the same story.
Title II has real consequences. Under Article 4 MiCA, an offeror of such tokens in the EU must be a legal person. It must draw up, notify and publish a white paper and keep its marketing communications compliant. Incorporation offshore does not take an offer outside MiCA if it reaches EU investors.
MiCA exempts small offers from the white paper obligations, for example:
These exemptions fall away where the offeror announces an intention to seek admission to trading (Article 4(4) MiCA). In our case, listing on an exchange is written into the contract as a condition, with a refund if it does not happen. A SAFT that makes listing a core promise is therefore a poor basis for relying on an exemption.
Two further points matter for retail investors. Retail holders buying directly from the offeror have a 14-day right of withdrawal (Article 13 MiCA). The offeror and its management body can also be liable for misleading information in the white paper (Article 15 MiCA).
In our case, most of the counterparty’s allocation pays for promotion, not for investment. The promoter is paid in the very token it promotes, and part of that pay unlocks at launch. This gives the promoter a direct interest in the token’s price in the first weeks of trading. Four sets of rules apply.
1. MiCA marketing rules. Under Article 7 MiCA, marketing communications must be clearly identifiable as such. They must be fair, clear and not misleading, and consistent with the white paper. A live session or a post presenting the project as an independent opinion does not meet that standard. The offeror is responsible for its marketing, including what it pays others to publish.
2. Market manipulation. Article 91 MiCA expressly treats as manipulation the use of media access to voice an opinion on a crypto-asset after taking a position in it, and then profiting from the price effect, without proper disclosure of that conflict of interest. The market abuse rules apply to crypto-assets admitted to trading or for which admission has been requested (Article 86(1) MiCA). A promoter holding tokens that unlock at listing fits this pattern closely. Clear and timely disclosure of both the position and the payment is the minimum safeguard.
3. Consumer protection and influencer law. Under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, using paid editorial content to promote a product without making the payment clear is always unfair. In Poland, this “crypto-advertising” is on the blacklist in Article 7(11) of the Act on Counteracting Unfair Market Practices. The President of UOKiK has issued recommendations on labelling influencer advertising and enforces them. In February 2025, UOKiK fined three well-known Polish influencers a total of almost PLN 500,000 for unlabelled advertising. Fines can reach 10% of turnover. These rules apply whenever content targets Polish consumers, wherever the influencer is based.
4. Platform rules. Under Article 26 of the Digital Services Act, online platforms must let users declare that content is a commercial communication. Failing to use that function makes the lack of disclosure harder to defend.
If the token qualified as a financial instrument, Polish rules on investment recommendations and unlicensed brokerage would also come into play. The practical lesson is simple: a promotion contract paid in tokens needs disclosure, lock-up and conduct clauses. The SAFT in our case had none.
Our SAFT says nothing about which law governs it or where disputes go. It even requires notices to be sent to email addresses “indicated in this SAFT”, but none are given. For a cross-border crypto deal, this is the most expensive omission.
Applicable law. A court in an EU Member State would apply the Rome I Regulation, which applies even where the chosen law is that of a non-EU state (Article 2). Without a choice of law, Article 4 points to the law of the party performing the characteristic obligation. For a token sale, that is usually the issuer delivering the tokens, so the law of an offshore seat would apply. The promotion element complicates this: it is a service performed by the other party. A court may find that the contract as a whole is more closely connected with another country (Article 4(3)). If the buyer is a consumer, Article 6 protects the law of the consumer’s habitual residence.
Whatever law applies, MiCA, EU consumer law and market abuse rules apply as overriding mandatory provisions (Article 9 Rome I).
Jurisdiction. The Brussels I bis Regulation generally does not cover defendants domiciled outside the EU. A Polish claimant suing an offshore issuer would rely on the Polish Code of Civil Procedure, for example the head of jurisdiction for contracts performed in Poland. Locating the place of performance of a token transfer to a wallet is uncertain. Even a Polish judgment would then need recognition in the issuer’s home jurisdiction.
What works in practice. Disputes involving offshore crypto counterparties are usually won or lost on assets. On-chain tracing can follow tokens and stablecoins to centralised exchanges, which can then be targeted with freezing orders. A clear governing law clause and an arbitration clause, for example under the rules of a recognised institution with a seat in the EU or London, make that process much faster. An arbitral award also benefits from the New York Convention.
If Polish law governs a SAFT, by choice or because a Polish party performs the characteristic obligation, several standard clauses work differently than their drafters expect.
| Clause | How Polish law treats it |
| Issuer sets the vesting schedule “in its sole discretion” | Freedom of contract has limits (Art. 353¹ KC). An obligation whose content one party may set at will risks being found contrary to the nature of the obligation, at least in that part. Inconsistent wording is read under Art. 65 KC, by the parties’ intention and the contract’s purpose. |
| Extra tokens for each month of late delivery | Delivering tokens is a non-monetary obligation, so a contractual penalty is permitted (Art. 483 KC). A court may reduce it if grossly excessive (Art. 484 §2 KC). Unless agreed, damages above the penalty cannot be claimed. |
| Refund as the “sole and exclusive remedy” | Liability may be limited between businesses, but not for damage caused intentionally (Art. 473 §2 KC). A refund in stablecoins is not a payment in legal tender, so statutory late-payment interest does not apply automatically. |
| Tokens provided “as is”, no warranties | Sale rules apply to the sale of rights (Art. 555 KC). Warranty can be excluded between businesses, but not if the seller fraudulently concealed a defect (Art. 558 KC). |
| Assignment only with the issuer’s consent | A valid restriction on assignment (Art. 509 KC). |
| Amendments only by “prior written consent” | Written form under Polish law means a handwritten or qualified electronic signature (Arts. 78 and 78¹ KC). A standard e-signature platform signature usually gives documentary form only. Parties should say which form they mean. |
| Severability | Mirrors the default rule in Art. 58 §3 KC. |
If the buyer is a consumer, the picture changes again. One-sided discretion and broad exclusions of liability are prime candidates for abusive clauses under Articles 385¹ to 385³ KC, and do not bind the consumer.
For a Polish-resident promoter, being paid in tokens is a barter. The tax authorities treat it in two stages.
Stage 1: when the service is performed. The fee due for the service is business income, whether or not it has been received and whatever form it takes. The Director of National Tax Information (KIS) has confirmed this in individual rulings, most recently in a ruling of 14 September 2026. The difficulty is valuation. Services are often performed before the TGE, when the token has no market price. The contractual price per token will usually be the starting point.
Stage 2: when the tokens are sold. Exchanging a virtual currency for legal tender, goods, services or property rights is a taxable disposal (Article 17(1f) of the PIT Act). According to the same KIS ruling, the value already recognised as income in stage 1 is the acquisition cost at stage 2. That prevents double taxation of the same value. The scheme only applies if the token is a “virtual currency” under the Polish AML Act. Some utility tokens may fall outside that definition and follow general rules instead.
VAT. Promotional services supplied to a business established outside Poland are generally taxed where the recipient is established (Article 28b of the VAT Act). They are therefore outside Polish VAT, but still need correct invoicing and reporting. Paying in tokens does not change the place of supply.
Visibility. Since 1 January 2026, crypto-asset service providers across the EU must report user transactions to tax authorities under DAC8. Token income that once went unreported is now far easier for tax authorities to trace.
Poland has still not adopted a law implementing MiCA. The President vetoed the crypto-assets market act three times. On 4 September 2026 the Sejm again failed to override the veto. The European Commission is conducting infringement proceedings against Poland (INFR(2025)2038).
The practical effects for business are significant:
For a SAFT counterparty, the gap is not a safe harbour. It means less supervision before problems arise, and more litigation after.
Issuers
Investors
Promoters and influencers
The SAFT in this case was cheap to draft and quick to sign. Its real cost sits in what it leaves out: an applicable law, a forum, disclosure rules for paid promotion and a classification that matches the token’s substance. In the EU, and especially in Poland’s current regulatory gap, those gaps fall on the parties themselves.
Małgorzata Kiełtyka, Radca prawny, Partner, KG Legal Kiełtyka Gładkowski sp.p. (mk@kg-legal.pl). This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. The case described is a composite and anonymised; it does not refer to any identifiable person or transaction.
ESMA, Article 4 MiCA (Interactive Single Rulebook)
ESMA, Article 91 MiCA (Interactive Single Rulebook)
ESMA, Overview of MiCA Level 2 and Level 3 measures (incl. qualification guidelines)
Money.pl, veto of the crypto-assets market act and infringement proceedings
Comparic, Crypto-assets without a statute
Prawo.pl, Latvia offers MiCA licences to Polish firms
Infor.pl, UOKiK fines for crypto-advertising
Prawo.pl, taxation of remuneration paid in crypto
Akademia LTCA, KIS ruling of 14 September 2026
KIELTYKA GLADKOWSKI is a Polish business law firm headquartered in Warsaw and Krakow, with a New York office under the iSTART1 brand. Building on a practice dating back to 1981, we advise clients in the following areas.
Select a practice area to learn more.
Service directory: kg-legal.eu/services