Publication date: November 17, 2026
For almost two decades, European universities measured research impact in patents, licences and spin-offs. The EU has since moved the goalposts. Under Council Recommendation (EU) 2022/2415 and four codes of practice adopted in 2023-2024, the benchmark is now “knowledge valorisation”: turning all intellectual assets, from data and know-how to standards and citizen science, into economic and societal value. In 2025-2026 the policy began to harden into binding law, with the European Innovation Act proposed in September 2026, a European Research Area (ERA) Act in the pipeline and the next Framework Programme (FP10, 2028-2034) under negotiation. Polish universities, still operating largely on a 2008-era technology transfer model under the Law on Higher Education and Science, have a narrowing window to adapt.
EU recommendations are not binding, yet they shape how research institutions write their internal rules and how projects get funded. Under Article 288 TFEU, recommendations and opinions “have no binding force”. Under Article 292 TFEU, the Council adopts recommendations, and the Commission (and, in specific cases, the European Central Bank) may also do so.
A recommendation creates no sanctions and no enforceable claims. Implementation depends on the goodwill of Member States and institutions. In practice, however, recommendations set the European standard: they are reflected in grant agreements, national strategies, evaluation criteria and university regulations. Ignoring them rarely carries a legal penalty, but it increasingly carries a funding and reputational one.
On 10 April 2008 the Commission adopted Recommendation 2008/416/EC on the management of intellectual property in knowledge transfer activities, with a Code of Practice for universities and other public research organisations (Annex I). Divergent national rules were hampering the European Research Area and cross-border cooperation. The goal was to link science more closely with industry and turn publicly funded research into tangible economic benefit.
The Code rested on three sets of principles:
Points 6 and 7 of Annex II called for resources, incentives and trained staff such as technology transfer officers. This drove the creation of technology transfer offices (TTOs) across Europe, focused on patent filings, patent sales, licensing and industry relations.
Council Recommendation (EU) 2022/2415 of 2 December 2022 on the guiding principles for knowledge valorisation formally replaced the 2008 Recommendation. Its preamble acknowledges the gains of the transfer model but calls for a move beyond technology and beyond a narrow, licence-and-patent view of value.
Knowledge valorisation is defined as the process of creating social and economic value from knowledge by linking different areas and sectors, and by transforming data, know-how and research results into sustainable products, services, solutions and knowledge-based policies that benefit society. Valorisation thus becomes a driver of social development, involving citizens and informing public policy.
The Recommendation sets seven guiding principles:
| Recommendation 2008/416/EC | Recommendation (EU) 2022/2415 | |
| Concept | Knowledge transfer (research, consultancy, licensing); commercialisation for economic growth | Knowledge valorisation: economic, social, policy and environmental value |
| Addressees | Public research organisations and universities | The whole R&I ecosystem: universities, NGOs, private investors, individuals, businesses, intermediaries, public authorities |
| Role of citizens | Passive recipients of economic benefits | Active participants in valorisation |
| Implementation | A single Code of Practice (Annex I) | Targeted codes of practice, with new codes added as needed |
Replacing the 2008 Recommendation did not end its practice overnight. Many grant agreements, funding schemes and university regulations still in force refer to its principles, so research institutions must be able to operate under both frameworks at once.
Between March 2023 and March 2024 the Commission adopted four codes of practice implementing Recommendation 2022/2415. Each translates the guiding principles into operational guidance for a specific channel of valorisation.
| Code of practice | Adopted | Core recommendations |
| Management of intellectual assets for knowledge valorisation in the ERA (Recommendation (EU) 2023/499) | 1 March 2023 | Adopt an intellectual asset management strategy compatible with open science and open innovation; clarify ownership and terms early in joint R&I; manage the path from creation to market through control measures, IP valuation, monitoring, transfer and licensing |
| Standardisation in the ERA (Recommendation (EU) 2023/498) | 1 March 2023 | Adopt a standardisation policy (standalone or within the IP policy); recognise standardisation in researcher careers and assessment; adapt TTOs; build standards into project design and impact; national support for SMEs and start-ups |
| Citizen engagement for knowledge valorisation (Recommendation (EU) 2024/736) | 1 March 2024 | Build an enabling environment with an organisational strategy, inclusion and gender equality, proper intellectual asset management, recognition of participants’ time and an evaluation framework; manage engagement with clear incentives, methods, communication and digital tools |
| Industry-academia co-creation for knowledge valorisation (Recommendation (EU) 2024/774) | 1 March 2024 | Strategy, awareness, skills, lifelong learning and networks; conditions for successful partnerships; support for intermediaries; evaluation of co-created value and impact |
The code on intellectual assets is the true successor to the 2008 Code. Its key move is conceptual: “intellectual assets” are broader than formal IP rights such as patents and copyright. They also cover publications, data, know-how and other R&I results, widening the scope for value creation and social innovation. The standardisation code treats standards as a valorisation route in their own right, supporting the free movement of goods, services and data, interoperability, the EU’s climate goals and its strategic autonomy.
The valorisation agenda is moving from voluntary guidance into legislation. Four developments matter for anyone managing intellectual assets in a research setting.
| Instrument | Status (as of November 2026) | Why it matters for intellectual assets |
| European Innovation Act | Proposed by the Commission on 9 September 2026, with a separate proposal for a Council Recommendation on regulatory sandboxes; now in the ordinary legislative procedure | Common EU methodology for IP valuation, a voluntary EUIPO certification scheme for IP valuators, a voluntary IP marketplace, an EUIPO competence centre on IP-backed finance; common procedure for joint cross-border R&D procurement, with the contractor keeping IP ownership by default in pre-commercial procurement |
| ERA Act | Announced for autumn 2026; the Commission indicated its core would be a regulation, possibly with parts as a directive | First binding legal framework for the European Research Area (“fifth freedom” of knowledge circulation), with focus on the 3% R&D target, research security, open science and research infrastructures |
| FP10 / Horizon Europe 2028-2034 (COM(2025) 543) | Proposed 16 July 2025; under negotiation for a planned start on 1 January 2028 | The draft rules for participation define “valorisation” as the use of results in further activities beyond the action, including commercial deployment; stronger emphasis on impact and exploitation |
| ERA Policy Agenda 2025-2027 (Council Recommendation of 24 June 2025) | In force (soft law) | Continues “upscaling knowledge valorisation capacities and activities” as a structural ERA policy |
The Innovation Act changes the economics of intellectual assets most directly. The Commission estimates a financing gap of up to EUR 18 billion a year for asset-light firms and expects its IP measures to unlock an additional EUR 10.2 billion a year in IP-backed venture and debt finance. For universities, a recognised valuation methodology could make their portfolios bankable for spin-offs. Commentators note an open question: the EUIPO’s expertise is in trademarks and designs, while patents fall to the European Patent Office, which is not an EU body.
The proposals are not yet law and their final texts may differ materially. The direction is clear, however: valorisation, IP valuation and impact reporting are becoming conditions of funding and market access, not optional good practice.
Poland’s Law of 20 July 2018 on Higher Education and Science (PSWiN, consolidated text Dz.U. 2024 item 1571, as amended) reflects both approaches, but its operative mechanisms remain anchored in the 2008 transfer model.
In practice, both technology transfer centres and special-purpose companies focus on classic commercialisation and business partnerships, in the spirit of 2008. Citizen engagement and social innovation, central to the 2022 framework, have little statutory footing. The Ministry of Science and Higher Education is preparing a broader PSWiN amendment, including a new model of research evaluation, which offers a natural opportunity to close this gap.
Consider a mid-sized public university with no intellectual asset or valorisation policy. It still follows the 2008 model: commercialisation, patenting and industry cooperation through its TTO. To align with current EU policy, its IP regulations should cover at least the following:
A simple disclosure process could run in four stages:
Revenue from licences or spin-off equity could be split 50% to the creator (a strong incentive to disclose), 25% to the faculty or institute (to sustain the team and further research) and 25% to the university (to fund valorisation activity). This is consistent with the PSWiN floor of 50% for the creator.
Finally, valorisation is not only commercial. Social innovation and citizen engagement can include community programmes (training, volunteering), citizen participation in research (for example health or environmental surveys), cooperation with local government and NGOs, and open access publication where social value is high and commercialisation is not needed.
The EU has moved from a 2008 model built on patents and licences to a 2022 framework that treats every intellectual asset as a potential source of economic and social value, and is now giving that framework legal teeth. Polish law and practice have absorbed the first model well but only partly the second. Institutions that update their IP regulations, incentives and asset management now will be better placed for FP10 funding, for IP-backed finance under the Innovation Act and for the ERA Act’s binding commitments.
KG Legal Kiełtyka Gładkowski·office@kg-legal.pl · www.kg-legal.eu
Services
KIELTYKA GLADKOWSKI is a Polish business law firm headquartered in Warsaw and Krakow, with a New York office under the iSTART1 brand. Building on a practice dating back to 1981, we advise clients in the following areas.
Select a practice area to learn more.
Service directory: kg-legal.eu/services
KG LEGAL KIELTYKA GLADKOWSKI offers legal support for research commercialisation and knowledge valorisation in Poland. Our assistance covers intellectual asset policies, technology licensing, R&D and consortium agreements, university spin-offs and IP obligations under funding agreements.
We help research organisations and commercial partners clarify ownership, access rights and responsibilities when developing and using research results.
Contact: office@kg-legal.pl.